A-STYLE | MEDIA MATTERS
  • News & Updates
  • For Patrons!
  • Editorials
  • Reviews
    • My Grading Scale
    • Top Lists
  • Behind the Scenes
    • About
    • FAQ
  • Fan-Works

The Golden Enclaves - Naomi Novik | Book Review

12/24/2022

0 Comments

 
          WOW. I knew it was going to be amazing, because every book in this series has been utterly astounding, but even with that high bar of expectation I was impressed.
            It perfectly continues the attack on the concept of an innately or naturally 'fair' society, aggressively transposing it's arguments of a rigged system from Education to the wider concept of governing Institutions as a whole. The whole notion of governance as as system existing in any state of beneficence at all is eloquently and poignantly ripped to shreds. As soon as Active Consensus becomes Systematized Bureaucracy, things start to tip away from any chance of being equitable, and while that's awful, you can't just blame the oppressors as straightforwardly selfish/evil. It's only rational to do what you can to keep your own as safe and comfortable as possible, even at the expense of others (especially if you don't have to personally witness, let alone execute, the cost).
Picture
       This novel is delightfully straightforward in its criticisms of society, and is also a perfectly wonderful story in its own right, one that simply hits harder for its critical poignancy. It's shorter than I wanted it to be, and a little to simplified to hone its point into something all but the most determinedly ignorant readers have to acknowledge as valid. 
            There's no one Big Bad, because the real world isn't that simple. The truly big bad in all of this is the concept that knowingly doing Evil is EVER justifiable, particularly when you have power. Ophelia is vile. But she wanted to do something good. The Chinese Dominus is also vile, also out of a desire to do good. The list goes on.
       Sex is a thing. That's just there. It happens. Repeatedly. And it MEANS SOMETHING DIFFERENT every time it does. El LOVES Orion, end of story. Whom she choses to have sex with in the chaos of grief and a frantic ping-ponging flight from one emergency to the next doesn't affect that at all. And he wouldn't care one whit. He wants to be permitted to be in her life however she will allow him to be there. It's not his place in anyway to judge her for her actions with other people if they haven't discussed it in any way, so he never does.
           It's not proactively focused on as a thematic point, but it's there, and I feel like I have to address it because it's the singular out-of-context detail that seems to be attracting the most hate from readers who refuse to engage with it critically.

            Also, El goes God-Mode! She has all the power in the universe and NONE OF IT MATTERS. Power isn't the answer. Power doesn't fix things. Power doesn't make things easier or better or safer or Good. All having power does is give you a legitimate choice. Because being a little bit Evil to protect your children by being complicit in a greater Evil isn't really a choice. Some people can break through that kind of thought, but a lot of people can't. There were plenty of normal people who joined the Nazi's because it was safer than fighting them. There are plenty of people who don't speak up to support gay rights because they have young children in school and if their kids's schoolmates get spoonfed hate for gay rights and their family is seen as gay sympathizers, their child will be bullied. There are plenty of kids who are bullied because their parents are vocal activists and to make it stop they adopt an aggressive anti-whatever attitude and themselves become aggressors. People can be awful, and the worst thing in the world is that they're usually at their worst for what they perceive as good reasons.
​
          Power doesn't solve problems. But it lets you have a legitimate choice in what you do about the issues you face.

​          The only thing that solves problems is the decision to be Good, no matter what. No compromise, no accepting the lesser Evil; it's not practical and it's not easy and it doesn't do much if you do it alone, but you can join the Nazis or join the French Resistance.

          All the little threads from across the series get tied up beautifully, and the story develops naturally with compelling twists and turns that make complete sense retroactively but are realizations that remain cleverly just out of reach until exactly the right moment -- when you realize that yeah, you kinda DID guess that, but had mostly dismissed it until it was confirmed.
        All the the characters grow and develop in a true-to-life manner, priorities change, motivations shift, good ideas lead to horrible outcomes and awful ones work out annoyingly well for terrible people, and grief hits everyone differently and deserves respect however it lands (even when it manifests in meanness or zombification).
   All in all, it's a glorious triumph of story that matters and it's probably the best example I've ever seen in modern times of adult fiction to explain why a story can't just be a story. I used to be firmly in the camp of 'why does it have to mean something to be good?', as many a snot-nosed teenager is when faced with a CritLit assignment... and as many adults default to as Capitalist Exhaustion makes comfort and ease more meaningfully significant than any awakening to consciousness ever could be, in a practical sense. This series is an excellent means by which to demonstrate why it's fundamentally untrue that a good story can ever just be a good story.
      One thing to be aware of is that is is NOT YA Fantasy, it is Adult Fantasy that is appropriate for YA readers. It might seem like splitting hairs, but there is a difference of both form and function between the two.
        There is no real romance in this. Orion's absent most of the time and there's two throw-away-ish sex scenes that only exist because El is an intensely inward-looking character that needs to be brought out of her head and into an awareness of her body. She's also impatient and always looking for cheat-codes. Sex is grounding. She could use drugs, meditation, music, or even an animal-friend (which is one thing she 
does do, but her animal isn't very effective because it's not very needy and only a few inches tall). The sex isn't meaningless, but it's also not romantically meaningful.

     Also, Orion as Manic-Pixie Dream Boy gets disintegrated. He's not a Hero worthy of swooning admiration. NO ONE IS. That's the point. Yeah, it reduces the YA sweeping romance adventure of it, but it's an important comment on how this world creates circumstances of inescapable pressures. You are born into circumstances, instilled with values, given particular skills and tools and experiences that shape your whole existence in ways that render your agency and personality nearly irrelevant. At best, your choices are the result of an attempt to be better than the worst you've seen and your ability to decide who you are isn't much more than cherry picking your favorite aspects of people/characters you've seen until around age 30, and even then it's iffy, you've just finally seen enough (generally) to start noticing broad patterns.
        Orion isn't a shining hero because he's heroic, he's heroic because that's what role he was molded to fill. BUT that doesn't not invalidate his personality, his humble humility is worthy of admiration, his desire to do right not just well is a laudable deviation from his Origin Matrix Ideology, and his relationship with El is a constant decision to revel in her existence that is the truest mark of Love I know. He is human and has choices but they only carry things so far, he's a hero because he tries to be and he's heroic because we want him to be.
       If you feel like this book is different than the other two in the trilogy, you weren't paying attention to the right things. This book is so consistent with the other two it's almost annoying... Until right up at the end when the Fantasy Happy Ending sweeps in to validate the theory of effort based solely on hope. There's no sweep-away story to get lost in here, and there's fewer fantastical distractions to marvel at, there's just a consistent and relentless deconstruction of societal preconceptions.
 
    There are a few things I would have liked more of, however:

           CHLOE. She deserved more attention, more of a substantive role. She could've played far more into this, and allowed for one more false-start investigation to pad out the narrative (it's not even 300 pages and I'm sad there's not enough to really dig my teeth into... it only took me a day to read, not even...). And it would've made Ophelia's villain-reveal have a little more weight. Ophelia's always been a villain, as a mom who clearly did Orion dirty in a number of usual shitty-childhood ways, but the transition from meh-mum to active antagonist could've been better. And we never get to see Chloe react / adjust to the reveal, which I think is a shame... it makes sense in context of El's focus and the plot direction, but I would have liked more.
      Less Repetition. It hits its point home hard. As a conclusion to a series, as the shift between specific circumstances and broad argument, and as a call to action that apparent futility is an insufficient reason not to try, I can see why Novik felt the need to be clear and insistent. But the book is hella short as it is and the repetition made it feel all the shorter.
         Actual Feelings. Yes. El is grieving. And Yes. El is awful at feelings to start with. And so is Liesel. (Hence the moderately unhealthy shortcut of sex). But I would have preferred she have someone with her to force her to stop and talk and FEEL. Chloe, again, could've been useful for this.

Overall? WONDERFUL.
           I am so unbearably pleased with it, that I've bumped this review to the top of my priority list, pushed it to the top of the publishing queue, and spent the last 2 hours actively commenting / critiquing the review of people who missed the point on Goodreads. I'll honestly have like 20 more pages of things to say about this book if I sit with it another week, and I will absolutely be bringing it up in every single class I have for the rest of my life probably (certainly for the foreseeable future), and it is 100% going into the curriculum I'm building (well, technically, only the first one, but this series...).
          If you have any interest in being a human being on any functional level beyond merely existing on the planet for a short while, you absolutely have to read this!
0 Comments
    If you have Questions about my Terminology, Bias Bands, or any other FAQ click HERE.

    Categories

    All
    100%
    1 The K (Loen Ent)
    2ne1
    2pm
    4 Minute
    9muses
    A6P
    AA (Double A)
    Academic
    A Ent Korea
    After School
    Ailee
    A-Jax
    Alice Nine
    AlphaBAT
    Amber
    Amie Kaufman
    AMUSE Inc
    Ann Pachett
    AoA (Ace Of Angels)
    AOMG
    Apink
    Art History
    * Artist Review *
    A-Sketch Ent
    Attack
    Audience: Adult
    Audience: New Adult
    Audience: Young Adult
    Audience: Young Reader
    B1a4
    B2m Ent
    Bangtan Boys
    B.A.P
    Bastarz
    Beast
    Believe Records
    Ben
    Benedict Carey
    Bestie
    B.I.G
    Big Bang
    Big Hit Ent
    Bigstar
    Block B
    BoA
    * Book Review *
    Boyfriend
    Boys Republic
    Brandnewmusic Korea
    Bravesound
    Brown Eyed Girls
    BTL (Beyond The Limit)
    Bugs! Korea
    Bumkey
    C2k Ent
    Can Ent
    C Clown
    C-Clown
    Chrome Ent
    CJ E&M
    CJes
    C-Jes Ent
    Cl
    CLC
    Collabodadi
    Core Contents Media
    *Cover Review*
    Crayon Pop
    CT Ent
    Cube Ent
    Cultural Studies
    Danal Ent
    Debut
    Diaura
    Donghae
    DS Ent
    Dsp Ent
    Dynamic Duo
    Equal Rep: LGBTQ+
    Equal Rep: Varied Gender Presentations
    ESNa
    Eunhyuk
    EXID
    Exo
    F.cuz
    Fiestar
    Fluxus Music
    Flying Dog Ent
    Fnc Ent
    Ft Island
    F(x)
    GaIn
    Galaxy Inc
    G Dragon
    G-Dragon
    General
    Genre: Cultural Studies
    Genre: Dark Fantasy
    Genre: Dystopia
    Genre: Epic Fantasy
    Genre: Fantasy
    Genre: Historical Fiction
    Genre: Literary Fiction
    Genre: Mythology
    Genre: Physics
    Genre: Plain Fiction
    Genre: Realistic Fiction
    Genre: Revisionary History
    Genre: Romance
    Genre: Science
    Genre: SciFi
    Genre: Space Opera
    Genre: Speculative Fiction
    GH Entertainment
    Giriboy
    Girls Day
    Girls Generation (SNSD)
    G.NA
    Gng Productions
    * Graphic Novel / Manga Review *
    Grisha Verse
    H2 Ent
    Happy Tribe Ent
    Henry
    Heo Youngsaeng
    High4
    History
    Hotshot
    House & Home Goods
    Imagine Dragons
    Infinite
    Information
    Instant Records
    Iu
    James Kakalios
    Jang HyunSeung
    Jay Park
    Jellyfish Ent
    Jennifer Armentrout
    Jimin N J.Don
    JinYoung Park (JYP)
    JMS Ent
    Js Ent
    JTM Ent
    J Tune Camp
    Jun HyoSung
    Jyj
    Jyp Ent
    Kahi
    Kang Seungyoon
    Kara
    Key East Ent
    Kim Hyungjun
    Kim Hyunjoong
    Kim Jaejoong
    KO Sound
    Kota
    KT Music
    K.Will
    Lc9
    Led Apple
    Lee Junghyun
    Leigh Bardugo
    Lim Kim
    Lindsey Stirling
    Lion Mascot (สิงโต นำโชค)
    Lunafly
    Madtown
    Mamamoo
    Marie Lu
    Marie Rutkoski
    Mblaq
    Meagan Spooner
    M.I.B
    Minah
    Miss A
    MMO Ent
    Mnet
    Monsta X
    Moonshine
    * Movie / Drama / TV Show Review *
    M.Pire
    Mr. Mr.
    Music K Ent
    * Music Review *
    My First Story
    Myname
    Mystic89 Music
    Nano
    Naomi Novik
    N.A.P Ent
    Neal Stephenson
    Nega Network
    N.Flying
    Nh Media
    Nine Muses
    Non Fiction
    Non-Fiction
    N-Sonic
    NS Yoon G
    NS Yoon-G
    NU'EST
    Odd Eye
    Oh Yeri
    Okdal
    One OK Rock
    Park BoRam
    Pentatonix
    Personal
    Phantom
    Pledis Ent
    Pocket Girls
    Pony Canyon Ent
    Prepix
    * Product Review *
    Psc Ent
    Queen B'z
    Rainbow
    Red Velvet
    Rex. D
    Rise Records
    Romeo
    ~Rookie Debut~
    Sabaa Tahir
    San-E
    Sarah J Maas
    Sean Carroll
    Secret
    Seo InGuk
    Series: Keeper Of The Lost Cities
    Series: Science Comics
    Seungri
    Seven Seasons Ent
    Seventeen
    Shannon Messenger
    Shinee
    SidusHQ
    Simtong Ent
    Sistar
    Skarf
    Sleeping With Sirens
    Sm Ent
    Sony Music & Ent
    Soulights
    Speed
    Spica
    S-Plus Ent
    Ss501
    Stardom Ent
    Star Empire Ent
    Starkim Ent
    Starship Ent
    Star Wars
    Stellar
    Sugarbowl
    SuJu D&E
    Sunmi
    Sunny Hill
    Super Junior
    Swings
    Taeyang
    Tahiti
    T-ARA
    Tasty
    The Ark
    *Theater & Stage Drama Review*
    The Benjamin Ent
    The British Royal Family
    The VIBE Ent
    Timothy Zahn
    Tiny G
    Tnc Ent
    Togeworl
    Top Class Ent
    Top Media
    Topp Dogg
    Toxic
    Ts Ent
    Tvn
    Tvxq
    U-Kiss
    Ulala Session
    UNIQ
    Universal Music
    UP10TION
    Urban Zakapa
    Various Artists
    Vibe: Aeronauts & Punk Diaspora
    * Video Review *
    Vixx
    WA Ent
    Warner Ent
    Wonder Boyz
    Wonder Girls
    Woolim Ent
    Xiah / Junsu
    Xiran Jay Zhao
    Year End Review
    Yedang Ent
    Yg Ent
    Ymc Ent
    YNB Ent.
    YNM Company
    Yuehua Ent
    ZE:A[제국의아이들]
    Z.Hera
    Zico

    Email Me!

    Archives

    December 2022
    November 2022
    July 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    September 2015
    August 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    May 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013

    My Tumblr

    RSS Feed

    The name, layout, opinions, analysis, and original media displayed on the Music Matters® website belongs to A-style® and are the intellectual property of Alexandra Swords. 2013©
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.